As a Tennessee tax attorney, I often represent small business owners who are delinquent in paying their payroll taxes, which are commonly referred to as an owner's "941 taxes." While the majority of these types of clients are seeking to resolve their tax debts with the Internal Revenue Service by civil means, a few of these cases are criminal in nature. Simply put, the Government views failure to pay provide payment for payroll taxes as theft, as the employer has taken money from an employee's check and failed to pay the withheld amounts to the IRS.
According to a press release from the Department of Justice, James and Theresa DeMuro of New Jersey each received 44-month prison sentences for conspiracy to defraud the Government and twenty-one counts of failing to pay payroll/employment taxes. The couple was also ordered to pay restitution of $1,337,952.12 to the IRS.
The couple's sentence came after a jury trial, where evidence was introduced that the couple withheld over a half-million dollars from their employees, but failed to pay any of this money to the IRS. The convicted couple also withheld money from employees' checks for health insurance, retirement accounts, and child support, but they also failed to provide these funds to the appropriate agencies or accounts. Instead, evidence was introduced showing that the DeMuros spent nearly $300,000 for purchases from Home Shopping Network, QVC, and Jewelry Television.